Idlib, Syria: The Distributed Community Health Care Proposal To Idlb Health Directorate
- Local Idlib NGOs continue to work with the chronically ill and the injured but supplies are drying up.
- International NGOs whose people had barely nudged the north of Idlib because of the inherent danger, have fled.
- The male-dominated Idlib Health Directorate and its trained workers are going strong “but may not be adapting fast enough nor are they taking advantage of past experience,” says a female surgeon in Idlib City.
“They (Idlib Health Direcorate) could better serve communities by accepting the necessity of war-time distributed community health care services,” say local doctors and nurses who seek “the utmost in mobility to discretely access chronically ill and acute cases in each community”. (Translated)
Women have tried to convince the men of the Idlib Health Directorate and the White Helmets that many health care workers should serve their community by working from their homes or nondescript clinics because the Russians and the Syrian Regime are bombing hospitals, clinics, and mobile medical units. The latter is the practice observed where combatants deliberately conduct military operations to force the displacement of large populations.
“If it’s on a map as a civilian health care facility, it will be bombed to scare the people away, such is the sick mind of Bashar al-Assad and the Iranian goons who are running his government,” says Simon Baldock, a security consultant in the region.
In recent days aircraft, from all accounts, Russian bombers have bombed two hospitals and in one case killed a RINJ EMS driver (ambulance driver), his patient, vehicle and assistant.
Losses of ambulance drivers and intake medics seems like a common occurrence in Syria. Probably that is because of their obvious attire, their big red crosses or crescents and their urgent driving technique. In other words they are clearly identified as being medical crews.
Editorial Note: This phenomena of attacking field medics and EMS drivers may also be attributable to the passionate hate by Assad, Rouhani and Putin’s ‘lieutenants‘ for the White Helmet group, many of whose members are former insurance agents or stock brokers who joined as volunteers. This ragtag group is gaining sophistication maybe because of their drive. They are people who had no more employment and wanted to do something useful for their community. Their medical incompetence has shown at times with contraindicated medical responses but that is out of urgency and lack of training, not wilfulness. They are a genuine community-based humanitarian group. Yes they have a passionate hatred for the people trying to kill them. Yes, that’s an apparent bias. But hatred for war criminals should be considered a normal emotion for those people who are not so immersed they have become numb to the violence as perhaps is true for this article’s authors.
Nobody loses sight of the fact that these people below are the women, children and their families that care-givers are fighting to protect. They are just ordinary people who want to be together, to be safe and happy. Please join the fight. Donate if you can’t volunteer.
The worst attacks are happening in the south of Idlib.
Katie Alsop of The RINJ Foundation has condemned the attacks on civilian gathering places including hospitals, children’s parks, residential homes and medical clinics.
RINJ Women advance that Locally trained medical workers have the capacity to work in their own communities if courier-delivered basic resupply is conducted discretely. That means no medical emblems. Photo Credit: Source submitted
“Idlib Health Directorate trained workers could operate in communities from their homes or from a patient’s house in a systematic war-zone technique that is less structured but more responsive to direct community needs than the Health Care System.” (Translated)
Lessons Learned in Iraq are being Applied Again in Syria as Idlib faces Early Stages of a Predicted Humanitarian Disaster
Training in Mosul Iraq is expected to resume after the current purge of people who lived in the city during the ISIS occupation. At one time beginning in 2013 after ISIS pushed many humanitarian workers out of Syria, Mosul was a shipping and storage depot plus assembly and training center in Iraq, close to vehicular routes.
American backed Iraqi Kurds have been rounding up and raping, killing or interning former residents of the ISIS era. A Kurdish source told Jessica, a RINJ nurse practitioner in Mosul that it was American CIA urging the round-up and not military officers. Ironically this is also the wish of Iranian backed elements in the Iraqi armed forces hence the crimes are being ignored if not encouraged by Baghdad. The head of the nursing school in Mosul said that wearing scrubs in Mosul is like wearing a target on one’s back. That is a familiar complaint, but one that has no apparent remedy, when in modern wars, American and Russian combatants oppose Muslims.
“It had been hoped that Mosul could be returned to its former status,” says Jessica, as an assembly, training, and supplies distribution centre.
“During the ISIS occupation, that role was ended and a company in Baghdad supplied medical oxygen, medical supplies and instruments until the owner of the company was robbed, shot and killed at a Kurdish checkpoint trying to deliver supplies to Mosul”, she added.
“What has happened in Mosul taught RINJ medical workers how to operate from distributed, masked community facilities. That includes community basements however, as in the case of Tamuz 17 in Mosul where Americans bombed and killed up to 200 civilians because an Iraqi Gold Division soldier foolishly called an air strike on a single sniper atop a two story roof, 10 families had congregated in basements along that street to share one single water filtration pump.
The civilians had been warned by the RINJ NGO not to congregate in such large numbers. “This is a lesson learned,” says nurse Sharon Santiago who is among her colleagues considered to be the logistics worker of miracles as the woman “with seven loaves and seven fishes to feed seven hundred“.
“When people are hungry or thirsty they will go and congregate to where the water is located. That is where they are vulnerable and where predators bomb them,” notes Santiago whose eyes became misty in memory of lost friends and their families.
As sad a statement this situation makes about human behaviour, it is no less true for being shocking. Idlib is again proving that this conduct is deliberate and not a coincidence.
“That is why smarter men than these brutes have made laws, albeit ignored laws, to prevent the attacking of some innocents,” says Santiago.
“Civilian infrastructure in the Middle East such as schools and hospitals are vulnerable to the brutal killers who bring genocidal war against civilians they dislike for race, color or creed which hatred erases all semblance of war-time concern for civilian lives. The human race has sunk to its lowest point in modern times and has begun to resemble the drawings on cave walls from paleolithic times, when humans were bashing each other on their heads with crude stone weapons.” — Katie Alsop, The RINJ Foundation
“Farah Sarmene, a 29-year-old displaced mother who arrived in Atma”, in Idlib province earlier this month, told Middle East Eye in Arabic that she was now “desperate” to feed her children as the world food programme (UN WFP) pulled out.
But as RINJ’s Dr. Buni points out after reading MME’s well-briefed article talking about the UN pullout, “they barely fed 50,000 people but there are over 800,000 families here in Idlib Governorate because it thus far has been the only safe haven, a “cease-fire zone” to bring your family if you are a displaced Syrian with at least some resources.”
* The Idlib demilitarization was an ongoing agreement between Turkey and Russia, acquiesced reluctantly to by Iran and Syria.
The Proof of What Needs to be done in Idlib by the locals lies in the Rubble of Raqqah and Mosul.
Most of the hospitals and schools in Mosul Iraq and ar-Raqqah Syria were bombed which is a categorical warning that medical workers and their facilities must become nondescript according to RINJ workers in Syria who have invented the concept of black or brown scrubs that look more like cargo pants and shirts than hospital attire. Photo Credit: RINJ Women – Facebook
Statement Issued from RINJ Idlib Workers on Facebook Page
No betrayal from the past is going to make much difference now to three million people in Idlib but whereas the Health Care Directorate has managed to maintain the highest possible standards for chronic patients and the acute cases, lack of supplies and support have caused a decay and the Russian and Syrian Regimes attacks on infrastructure will lead to the eventual death of health care as we know it to exist in Idlib for three million people.
The RINJ Foundation personnel in the region are indigenous Syrians and will maintain a listening and observing watch to gather evidence and condemn the Russian, Iranian and Syrian Regime and any other actors including the sub-human conduct of the Hayat Tahrir al-Sham (who mimic the aforementioned) for there war crimes and crimes against humanity. There are no actors with the color of right including the Turkish interlopers.
With all due respect, RINJ urges the men of the Idlib Health Care Directorate to adopt a distributed emergency health care system for courier distribution of available supplies and close-community medical support for crush and suffocation injuries and both acute and chronic care.
The combatants against Idlib’s people intend to cause massive displacement and they will attack known hospitals, clinics, mosques, schools and all known civilian support centre-points. (translated)
Additional Background Reading
Refugee families returning home might be the effectiveness measure of peacemaking and humanitarian action in war-torn areas. But returning refugees might also indicate conditions in the refugee-hosting nation are so bad that anything would be better. Notwithstanding this dilemma of Syrian migrants, … Continue reading
Unsung Heroes in Syria, Recep Erdogan and Vladimir Putin saved thousands. Parties must now respect the peace in Idlib. That is exactly what medical workers in the city of Idlib are telling Feminine Perspective Magazine. by Melissa Hemingway, Feminine Perspective … Continue reading
Questions and Answers A US-sponsored assassination of Bashar al-Assad was alleged to have been discussed or even planned by US President Donald Trump. That is not too surprising, is it? Somebody had a bullet for good people like Abraham, Martin … Continue reading
Idlib is scheduled for Total Destruction by 3-Pariahs The three-pariahs cannot be trusted. They have used chemical weapons; have slaughtered half a million women and children; attacked civilian medical infrastructure; put a price on the heads of white-coats (nurses, doctors, … Continue reading
Civilian Evacuation from Idlib, Syria continues today amid bombing attacks by Russia. Most people do not have the means to evacuate. Some 3 million people in the larger Idlib region are endangered by advancing Syrian Arab Army and Russian bombers or … Continue reading